| NAME | SCHOOLS | CLASS |
| Mark Alberts Sr. | Wooster | 2007 |
| Bob Anderson | Anna | 2005 |
| Tom Andreas | Dover | 1998 |
| *Richard Armstrong | OHSAA Commissioner | 2002 |
| Bob Arnzen | Delphos St. John’s | 1995 |
| Charles “Red” Ash | Canton South | 1988 |
| Carl Bachman | Findlay | 1987 |
| J. Daniel Baker | Delaware Hayes | 1988 |
| Roy Bates | Northwestern | 1989 |
| Dave Bell | Zanesville | 1997 |
| Dick Berning | St. Xavier | 1996 |
| Alan Bowen | Columbus Central | 1993 |
| Paul Bricker | Convoy Crestview | 1999 |
| Rick Brook | Sebring | 2001 |
| Alan Burns | Boardman | 1997 |
| John Cabas | Salem | 1987 |
| Jim Cappelletti | Cleveland Heights | 2011 |
| Larry Chernauskas | Cleveland West Tech | 2004 |
| Vince Chickerella | Linden McKinley | 1995 |
| Larry Clark | Perrysburg | 2003 |
| Will Collins | Bellefontaine | 2002 |
| Jack Clouse | Celina | 2006 |
| Fred Church | Napoleon | 1988 |
| Tom Cuppert | Chillicothe | 1993 |
| Harold “Doc” Daugherty | Euclid | 2002 |
| Tom Davis | East Canton | 2012 |
| Jerry Doerger | Cincinnati McNicholas | 2011 |
| *Don Donoher | University of Dayton | 2000 |
| Max Douglas | Newark | 1990 |
| Tom Eibel | New London | 2010 |
| *Wayne Embry | Tecumseh, Miami University | 2004 |
| Ray Etzler | Convoy Crestview | 1996 |
| Charles “Bud” Felhaber | Oregon Clay | 2004 |
| Gene Ford | Cambridge | 2007 |
| *Bevo Francis | Rio Grande University | 1999 |
| Mitch Gillam | Lorain Admiral King | 1993 |
| Dick Graeff | Arcanum | 1992 |
| Jack Greathouse | Lancaster | 2010 |
| Russ Gregg | Columbus Whitehall | 1992 |
| Jack Greynolds | Barberton | 1992 |
| Fran Guilbault | St. Henry | 2001 |
| Robert Guinta | Elyria Catholic | 1991 |
| Bob Haas | Willard | 1996 |
| *Magellan Hairston | Waterloo Wonders | 1996 |
| Walter Harrop Sr. | Shawnee | 1987 |
| Walter Harrop Jr. | Ashland | 2001 |
| *Bob Hart | Columbus East | 2010 |
| CD Hawhee | Waverly | 1989 |
| Louis Heckman | Ottoville | 1990 |
| George Heller | Portsmouth | 1992 |
| Don Henderson | Springfield North | 1991 |
| Paul Highnam | Danville | 2006 |
| Lee Himmeger | Ayersville | 1998 |
| Columbus Hines | New Lebanon Dixie | 1987 |
| Vern Hoffman | Mansfield | 1987 |
| Larry Holden | Beavercreek | 2005 |
| Dave Hoover | Canton McKinley | 2008 |
| *Bill Hosket | Belmont, Ohio State | 2005 |
| Charles Huggins | Indian Valley South | 1993 |
| Paul Johnson | Lowellville | 1990 |
| Larry Jordan | Southeastern | 2011 |
| Arch Justus | Portsmouth Clay | 1995 |
| Bill Kaylor | Xenia | 1989 |
| Steve Kick | Loudonville | 1997 |
| Stan Kirby | Marion Pleasant | 1997 |
| Richard Kiser | Eastern Brown | 2012 |
| Richard Kortokrax | Kalida | 1999 |
| Dave Krauss | Patrick Henry | 2008 |
| Jim Lawhead | Lorain Catholic | 2002 |
| Henry Lazasz | Warren Consolidated | 1998 |
| James Lower | Canal Fulton Northwest | 2010 |
| Charles Maier | Coldwater | 2000 |
| Charles McAfee | Athens | 1987 |
| Robert McClary | McDonald | 1991 |
| Marv McCollum | Hamilton | 1987 |
| *Ray Mears | Wittenberg University | 1995 |
| *Tom Metters | The Athens Messenger | 1993 |
| Gene Millard | Bexley | 1990 |
| Jackie Moore | Columbus Walnut Ridge | 1988 |
| Hank Morus | Frontier | 1994 |
| Richard Meyer | Buckeye Valley | 1989 |
| *Clair Muscaro | OHSAA Commissioner | 2008 |
| Ken Newlon | Canton McKinley | 1987 |
| Joe Petrocelli | Archbishop Alter | 1999 |
| Frank Phillips | Chagrin Falls | 2008 |
| Jane Poeppelman | Fort Loramie | 1998 |
| Dick Potts | River | 1994 |
| Gretchen Prichard | Lima Bath | 2000 |
| Herman “Bup” Rearick | Canton McKinley | 1988 |
| Perry Reese Jr. | Berlin Hiland | 2001 |
| Dale Reichenbach | Elyria Senior | 1995 |
| Tom Rettig | Tippecanoe | 2009 |
| Mike Riley | Canton McKinley | 2009 |
| John “Butch” Rossi | Middletown Fenwick | 1995 |
| Herb Russell | Grove City | 1991 |
| Jack Ryan | Columbus St. Charles | 1992 |
| Bob Seggerson | Lima Central Catholic | 2011 |
| Gary Shaffer | Washington Court House | 2004 |
| *Frank Shannon | Ohio Wesleyan University | 1994 |
| Rob Sheldon | Bucyrus Wynford | 2005 |
| *Bob Shoemaker | Heath / Big Walnut | 2006 |
| Joe Siegferth | Akron Central Hower | 1991 |
| Dave Sladky | Wadsworth | 1998 |
| Steve Smith | Orrville | 2003 |
| *Tim Smith | Sylvania Northview | 2007 |
| Keith Sooy | Medina | 2003 |
| Allen Souder | Fort Recovery | 2009 |
| David Sweet | Ottawa Glandorf | 2008 |
| *Fred Taylor | The Ohio State University | 1991 |
| Henderson “Heckie” Thompson | Western | 1989 |
| Rick Van Matre | Greenfield McClain | 2012 |
| Jack Van Reeth | West Holmes | 2012 |
| Rich Voiers | Bay Village | 1996 |
| *Fran Voll | Delphos St. John’s / Bowling Green | 2003 |
| Paul Walker | Middletown | 1987 |
| Bob Walsh | Elyria | 2007 |
| Gary Walters | Newark | 2002 |
| Chuck Watt | Steubenville | 1994 |
| Al Welch | Wayne Trace | 2009 |
| John Wickline | Rio Grande | 1994 |
| Ben Williams | Toledo Scott | 2000 |
| Larry Wilson | Perry | 1997 |
| Wayne Wiseman | Springfield South | 1990 |
| John Woolums | Dayton Roosevelt | 1993 |
| Glenn Wyville | Chagrin Falls | 1999 |
| Ray Zawadski | Vandalia Butler | 2006 |
| Lee Zierolf | Sandusky St. Mary’s | 2003 |
| * Denotes Honorary Life Member | ||
