The Ohio High School Basketball Coaches Association selects Mr. Basketball in Boys Basketball each year. The procedures for the selection of Mr. Basketball is (1) that the Player must be nominated by a District Director or Officer, (2) Nominees can be a senior or underclassman, (3) Each player’s stats will be discussed among the District Directors and Officers and (4) District Director will vote to determine the winner.
| YEAR | PLAYER | SCHOOL |
| 2012 | Terry Rozier | Shaker Heights |
| 2011 | Travis Trice | Huber Heights Wayne |
| 2010 | Jared Sullinger | Columbus Northland |
| 2009 | Jared Sullinger | Columbus Northland |
| 2008 | William Buford | Toledo Libbey |
| 2007 | Jon Diebler | Upper Sandusky |
| 2006 | Raymar Morgan | Canton McKinley |
| 2005 | Jamelle Cornley | Columbus Brookhaven |
| 2004 | Jamar Butler | Lima Shawnee |
| 2003 | Lebron James | Akron St. Vincent |
| 2002 | Lebron James | Akron St. Vincent |
| 2001 | Lebron James | Akron St. Vincent |
| 2000 | Romaine Sato | Dayton Christian |
| 1999 | Brooks Hall | Troy |
| 1998 | Keith McLeod | Canton McKinley |
| 1997 | Andre Hutson | Trotwood Madison |
| 1996 | Jason Collier | Springfield Catholic |
| 1995 | Shaun Stonerook | Westerville North |
| 1994 | Byron Gladden | Lorain Admiral King |
| 1993 | Damon Flint | Cincinnati Woodward |
| 1992 | Greg Simpson | Lima Senior |
| 1991 | LaZelle Durden | Rossford |
| 1990 | Tyrice Walker | Hamilton |
| 1989 | Jimmy Jackson | Toledo Macomber |